I wrote a letter to the LA Times this week and it was published. Below are the links to both the article and the letter! The story pertained to the screening of inmates by the Sheriff Department for immigration status. I commented on the "sad" story of a Mexican immigrant who was about to be deported for the third or fourth time who has a wife and kids at home.
The Article: http://www.latimes.com/news/local/immigration/la-me-immigjail22-2008jun22,0,2078919.story
The Letter: http://www.latimes.com/news/opinion/letters/la-le-wednesday25-2008jun25,0,5377661,full.story
Wednesday, June 25, 2008
Monday, June 23, 2008
Diversity and Tolerance: The Culture Wars
Last "holiday season" a rabbi filed suit against a Seattle Airport in order to have a Chanuka Menorah placed alongside the usual Christmas Tree (or is it Holiday Tree now?). While many people were mad at him for possibly having the tree removed, as it almost was, I am more upset that there is a tree up in the first place. While many might disagree with me politically regarding what a government should and should not do, I cannot see that anyone can really argue that government spending on any decorations for any holiday are warranted or even an acceptable use of public funds. If a private business chooses to place a decoration up that is their business.
In recent years Target has been criticized for taking the word Christmas out of the store sales and making it merely a "Winter Holiday Season.” Many people are upset over this but Target is a business and I can only assume that in an effort to best serve its customers it made an educated choice which a private (not governmentally owned) business may do.
The main reason for all of this hullabaloo is that diversity has created a climate where we expect all cultures to be represented or at least have a chance at being represented in every situation. This exposure to the cultures of others, while enlightening, has actually watered down the cultures into marketable clichés. A Christmas tree somehow became the symbol of a Christian holy day and a marketable symbol at that. The holidays of Kwanzaa and Chanuka are treated as sidekicks to Christmas just because they happen to fall during the same so called “holiday season.” Christmas and Chanuka have absolutely nothing in common. They are probably the anti-thesis of each other if one really studies the true meaning and history of each.
When diversity makes all cultures seem relative to each other the real differences are masked. It is for this reason people like quotes such as “we are all people” or “we all live on the same planet” or “can’t we all just get along?” and forget that individual cultures have different views on what behavior is acceptable and what getting along means. While a Muslim community in the Middle East may be viewed as backwards in their treatment of women or how they live, this is their culture. Any attempt to homogenize them or incorporate modern notions of the best way to live would destroy that culture.
Are some cultures worth destroying? That depends upon the particular view of each culture and within it, the majority of its participants. Certainly, any culture has a right to defend its way of life. The resulting wars and killings may seem harsh but are necessary for the preservation of civil societies. By civil societies I mean independent cultures that operate on their own and take care of the needs of the people within the culture.
Diversity in its current incarnation has created a world of supposed equality amongst cultures. The results are terrible. It has become impossible for any culture to attempt to defend itself without being told by the UN to stop or risk sanctions. The West fights the East and the Islamic Terrorists fight the World. Meanwhile, people think that if we all just understand each other a bit better we will avoid all this strife. By “understand” they mean let things go that are fundamental to the very core of their own culture. How can a Jewish person let go of an ingrained hatred of Jews by the Palestinians? How can the feminists let go of their belief that women should be equal to men? Certainly in a country with Islamic rule this will not happen.
Should we then forget this and make peace anyhow?
In order for any culture to survive it must fight for its own beliefs. This is an essential characteristic of a culture. It has a definite identity and a strong identification of its members. Additionally, the members are willing to defend their culture as it exists or lose and become another culture.
As private citizens living within our own cultures and intermingling with other cultures we maintain a dual citizenship in both the outside world and our own cultures. We feel this difference every day when we deal with those outside of our own culture. The main reason American society has lasted as long as it has is due to the government’s ability to remain out of the sphere of culture and religion. This is why many oppose church and state mingling or government funding for anything other than national defense and infrastructure interests. Any more intermingling affects the individual cultures within American society and makes a homogenous society with nothing worth fighting for but much fighting about what exactly is.
In the end we have societies fighting for inconsistent reasons. This is one reason the War on Terror” is so debated. There is a large block of people that do not understand why the fight exists in the first place. Since diversity has taught them that all cultures are allowed to freely exist and no other culture may assert any dominance over another there is never a reason to fight, even when another culture actually does attempt to assert dominance over others.
I may have digressed far from my original scenario involving Christmas Trees and Chanuka Menorahs in airports but this is exactly where this scenario leads us to when all cultures must always be represented at every moment and at every time by selectively taking aspects of each and attempting, on a micro scale, to blend them into a “holiday season” or, on the macro scale, a global culture.
(This blog is a previously written piece I placed in my computer archives in anticipation of creating a blog. Now that I have a blog I am slowly editing and releasing my writings. Enjoy!)
In recent years Target has been criticized for taking the word Christmas out of the store sales and making it merely a "Winter Holiday Season.” Many people are upset over this but Target is a business and I can only assume that in an effort to best serve its customers it made an educated choice which a private (not governmentally owned) business may do.
The main reason for all of this hullabaloo is that diversity has created a climate where we expect all cultures to be represented or at least have a chance at being represented in every situation. This exposure to the cultures of others, while enlightening, has actually watered down the cultures into marketable clichés. A Christmas tree somehow became the symbol of a Christian holy day and a marketable symbol at that. The holidays of Kwanzaa and Chanuka are treated as sidekicks to Christmas just because they happen to fall during the same so called “holiday season.” Christmas and Chanuka have absolutely nothing in common. They are probably the anti-thesis of each other if one really studies the true meaning and history of each.
When diversity makes all cultures seem relative to each other the real differences are masked. It is for this reason people like quotes such as “we are all people” or “we all live on the same planet” or “can’t we all just get along?” and forget that individual cultures have different views on what behavior is acceptable and what getting along means. While a Muslim community in the Middle East may be viewed as backwards in their treatment of women or how they live, this is their culture. Any attempt to homogenize them or incorporate modern notions of the best way to live would destroy that culture.
Are some cultures worth destroying? That depends upon the particular view of each culture and within it, the majority of its participants. Certainly, any culture has a right to defend its way of life. The resulting wars and killings may seem harsh but are necessary for the preservation of civil societies. By civil societies I mean independent cultures that operate on their own and take care of the needs of the people within the culture.
Diversity in its current incarnation has created a world of supposed equality amongst cultures. The results are terrible. It has become impossible for any culture to attempt to defend itself without being told by the UN to stop or risk sanctions. The West fights the East and the Islamic Terrorists fight the World. Meanwhile, people think that if we all just understand each other a bit better we will avoid all this strife. By “understand” they mean let things go that are fundamental to the very core of their own culture. How can a Jewish person let go of an ingrained hatred of Jews by the Palestinians? How can the feminists let go of their belief that women should be equal to men? Certainly in a country with Islamic rule this will not happen.
Should we then forget this and make peace anyhow?
In order for any culture to survive it must fight for its own beliefs. This is an essential characteristic of a culture. It has a definite identity and a strong identification of its members. Additionally, the members are willing to defend their culture as it exists or lose and become another culture.
As private citizens living within our own cultures and intermingling with other cultures we maintain a dual citizenship in both the outside world and our own cultures. We feel this difference every day when we deal with those outside of our own culture. The main reason American society has lasted as long as it has is due to the government’s ability to remain out of the sphere of culture and religion. This is why many oppose church and state mingling or government funding for anything other than national defense and infrastructure interests. Any more intermingling affects the individual cultures within American society and makes a homogenous society with nothing worth fighting for but much fighting about what exactly is.
In the end we have societies fighting for inconsistent reasons. This is one reason the War on Terror” is so debated. There is a large block of people that do not understand why the fight exists in the first place. Since diversity has taught them that all cultures are allowed to freely exist and no other culture may assert any dominance over another there is never a reason to fight, even when another culture actually does attempt to assert dominance over others.
I may have digressed far from my original scenario involving Christmas Trees and Chanuka Menorahs in airports but this is exactly where this scenario leads us to when all cultures must always be represented at every moment and at every time by selectively taking aspects of each and attempting, on a micro scale, to blend them into a “holiday season” or, on the macro scale, a global culture.
(This blog is a previously written piece I placed in my computer archives in anticipation of creating a blog. Now that I have a blog I am slowly editing and releasing my writings. Enjoy!)
Thursday, June 5, 2008
Scripps Spelling Bee
After a long day of errands, studying, and drivng I decided to sit down and watch the Scripps Spelling Bee that I DVRed over Memorial Day Weekend. The annual event was televised by ABC and actually gets some ratings. I find it ho-hum that these kids can spell as well as they do but amused at the way they do it. Wthout fail they all ask for the word to be used in a sentence, the form of the word, alternate pronunctiations, and origins. After asking this, they again want it in a sentence or ask other questions. Then they spell it and get all happy when they get it right.
While the ability to spell is amazing in today's modern world of spell check, it would be even more amazing if the kids knew the meaning of the words they can spell. The spelling bee is a memorization contest. Oddly enough, the commentators make claims that some are more experienced or are favored to win it all. How can someone be more experienced? The words change every time. It does not matter how many times you have been in the finals before, the next time is a completely different game. Also, favored to win? Do they follow the contestants around and see their study routines or something? How does one pick a favorite in the spelling bee?
The kids also look like social misfits. The kids look like they spend their entire lives reading a dictionary. This is as cool as they will ever be! They get to be on TV, interviewed between rounds about how they feel and their approach. "What was going through your mind as you were trying to spell ommateal (of, relating to, or having compound eyes, adjective)?" Answer "I was trying to remember the letters of the alphabet."
Why does the bee have an age limit? Is an adult expected to know how to spell words like boulangere (cooked with sliced onions in a casserole, adjectve)? Doubtful. I would love to see an adult bee or one with the definitions as well!
While the ability to spell is amazing in today's modern world of spell check, it would be even more amazing if the kids knew the meaning of the words they can spell. The spelling bee is a memorization contest. Oddly enough, the commentators make claims that some are more experienced or are favored to win it all. How can someone be more experienced? The words change every time. It does not matter how many times you have been in the finals before, the next time is a completely different game. Also, favored to win? Do they follow the contestants around and see their study routines or something? How does one pick a favorite in the spelling bee?
The kids also look like social misfits. The kids look like they spend their entire lives reading a dictionary. This is as cool as they will ever be! They get to be on TV, interviewed between rounds about how they feel and their approach. "What was going through your mind as you were trying to spell ommateal (of, relating to, or having compound eyes, adjective)?" Answer "I was trying to remember the letters of the alphabet."
Why does the bee have an age limit? Is an adult expected to know how to spell words like boulangere (cooked with sliced onions in a casserole, adjectve)? Doubtful. I would love to see an adult bee or one with the definitions as well!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Posts
